The Proof is in the Testimonies, 1 John 5:6-12
In 8th grade, I wrote a Christmas play for elementary students. In the script, a group of kids traveled back in time to the scene of Jesus’ birth (true, not the most original plot!). I gave it the title, “Eye-Witness Christmas”. Complete with classic bathrobe costumes and refrigerator-box-turned-time-machine, the play climaxed with the actors’ strengthened faith because of what they saw and heard beside the manger. I wouldn’t have been able to articulate it back then, but perhaps part of the reason I was drawn to the idea of eye-witness testimonies, was to emphasize to my heart that my wavering faith could steady itself on Jesus being true rather than on my testimony being radical.
Eye-witnesses attest to what they experience, and although individuals see from various angles and viewpoints, cohesion between them points to truth. John himself was an eye-witness to Jesus’ life, and he opened this book with “the life was made manifest, and we have seen it, and testify to it…” 1 John 1:2. He and the other apostles could be sure about who Jesus was, because God left them with clear evidence. He longs to strengthen our faith by their witness.
Jesus’ identity is confirmed by three striking testimonies: the Spirit, the water, and the blood. Having spent most of the book analyzing our personal lives for evidence of eternal life, 1 John 5:6-12 turns our attention to the One who is the foundation of eternal life. The Spirit, the water, and the blood agree about who Jesus is, like first-hand witnesses.
The testimony of the Spirit. Across time, the Spirit of God has been invariably testifying about the identity of the Messiah. He prompted prophecy after prophecy about the Messiah’s arrival, describing in scripture what He would be like, what He would accomplish, and how He would suffer. Jesus came and fulfilled His time on earth, and then He returned to His Father. In His physical absence, the Spirit was sent to dwell in His followers to comfort and convict, teach and transform, growing them into Christlikeness. When we confess Christ as personal Savior, it’s evidence of this same Spirit testifying within us to the truth of Jesus. The consistent witness of the Spirit is the reason John says we must “test the spirits” to see whether they’re in alignment with what the Spirit has been saying all along about Christ.
The testimony of the water. All four Gospels include the baptism of Jesus at the launch of His public ministry. There, the sights and sounds by the water’s edge fulfilled predictions from the prophet Isaiah that the Spirit of the Lord would rest upon the Messiah, the beloved One of God, anointed to bring good news to the people. On-lookers at His baptism could remember these prophecies and realize that Jesus was God’s long-awaited Chosen One. The Bible knowledge Commentary explains that a false belief in the first century claimed “that the divine Christ descended on the man Jesus at His baptism and left Him before His crucifixion.” In other words, Jesus was a mere human, only partially and temporarily inhabited by God, and He could not pay for sinners’ salvation, since He was just a man when He died. This kind of denial that Jesus is God in the flesh is anti-Christ, one of the repeated warnings in this book and the reason we stand on the additional witness of His blood.
The testimony of the blood. This isn’t the first time we’ve read about blood in 1 John. Back in 1:7, we read that “the blood of Jesus Christ, [God’s] Son, cleanses us from all sin.” And in 2:2, we’re told that “[Jesus] is the propitiation for our sins.”
To understand the purpose of Jesus’ bloodshed, we look back to the Old Testament. Animal sacrifices offered on behalf of God’s people depicted and anticipated The Lamb of God who would once and for all be the atoning sacrifice for sin. This Lamb would bear God’s just wrath against sin, removing its penalty and defeating its power for all who would put their trust in His life as their substitutionary payment. What the lambs’ blood could not do in the past, Jesus did, cleansing His followers from the inside out.
Although our salvation testimonies are each unique works of God, our faith isn’t built on subjective experiences. Faith rests on the historical reality of Jesus, testified to by the Spirit, the water, and the blood. Together, they uphold and unify our individual testimonies as the common ground we share by faith in Christ. As intriguing as time travel may be, the evidence is strong enough without it.
“And this is the testimony, that God us eternal life, and this life is in His Son.” 1 John 5:11
Before & After, 1 John 5:6-12
I love seeing a house transformed…
I love seeing a house transformed from lifeless to energized, and I always smile at a homeowner’s shock that it was even possible.
But I’ve never gasped in delight about the electric being rewired (Before, it was a mangled fire hazard, but now just look how orderly and straight it is!). I haven’t shaken my head in wonder because the water heater was replaced (Before, only the early risers got hot showers, but now even the teenagers do!). I haven’t sat down to take in the details about the HVAC being installed (Before, we would shiver in winter and sweat in summer!). As major as these changes are, they just don’t have the visual appeal I’m expecting.
Salvation testimonies are before and after stories, and we love to hear about drastic visible changes in a life. And we should! But the primary changes in salvation are unseen realities that tend to be forgotten behind the drywall of visible change. Children who grow up learning about Jesus and who trust Him at early ages must be reassured that before and after is first spiritual, or we’ve done a disservice to our kids in the church service.
Platforming only the type of testimonies that have visible before and after changes, raises doubts in children and teens about whether their salvation experience is as valid as someone who has a lifestyle transformation story; they feel pressured to concoct a before about themselves; they’re convinced that - at best - their testimony is just plain boring, and - at worst - invalid. As parents or grandparents, youth workers or pastors, we can play a role by celebrating the spiritual before and after testimony just as wildly as we applaud a visible before and after.
Before, I was lost, but now I’m found. Luke 15:24
Before, I was dead, but now I’m alive. Ephesians 2:4,5
Before, I was far from God, but now I’m near. Ephesians 2:13
Before, I was in debt, but now I’m forgiven. Colossians 2:13-15
Before, I was enslaved, but now I’m freed. Hebrews 2:14,15
Any changes Christ makes in our lives are reasons for joy and evidence of His presence, but our individual stories are not the foundation upon which the truth of Jesus ultimately rests. In chapter 5:6-12, John takes us from analyzing our lives and turns our attention outside of ourselves to the identity of the One who is the foundation of our eternal life.
Jesus is not the Messiah because He changed my life and fulfilled me;
Jesus is the Messiah because He gave His life and fulfilled prophecy.
Jesus isn’t the Chosen One because I picked Him over Muhammed or Buddah;
He’s Chosen because the Father declared it and the Spirit affirmed it.
Jesus isn’t the payment for sin because I feel forgiven and free;
Jesus is the payment for sin because the Lamb of God takes away the sin of the world.
These three striking testimonies - the Spirit, the water, and the blood - define Jesus, upholding and uniting our various individual testimonies as the common ground we share by faith in Him.
Have you celebrated your own spiritual before & after? Have you ever encouraged a teen who confessed Christ as a child by celebrating their spiritual before & after?
Q&A, 1 John 4:7-5:5
Sometimes a passage of scripture is so saturated with insight that it’s helpful to approach it one question at a time. With the word love repeated over 30 times here, we can press into its message, first from one direction and then from another, soaking in the wealth of truth that drips from the page and giving our hearts time to absorb each answer.
What is true about God?
God is love. 4:8,16
This is hardest for me to believe when…
This is easiest for me to believe when…
Why did the Father send His Son?
So that we might live through Him 4:9
To be the propitiation for our sins 4:10
To be the Savior of the world 4:14
Life, atonement for my sin, and saving the world - in what ways have I assumed responsibility for any of these myself instead of depending on Jesus for them?
What did Jesus reveal about God’s love?
His love appeared among us 4:9
His love existed prior to our love, and it enables us to love 4:10,19
His love is the model for us to imitate in our relationships 4:10,11
What if I spent some time in one of the gospels and specifically noted all the people Jesus loved and the various ways He showed it?
When I believe in Jesus, what happens?
God abides in me, & I abide in God 4:15
It shows that I am born again 5:1
I overcome the world 5:5
Which of these realities am I most grateful for today?
How can I be sure God abides in me?
My love for other believers 4:12,16
The witness and work of the Spirit in me 4:13,14
My belief in Christ 4:15 Looking back, how have I seen one of these grow in my life?
When I put God’s love in action by loving other believers, what happens?
It shows my rebirth 4:7
It shows I know the Source of love 4:7,8
I imitate God’s love 4:11,19
It shows that God abides in me 4:12,16
God’s love in me grows into maturity 4:12
I become like Jesus in this world 4:17
I become confident rather than fearful 4:17,18
I obey God’s command 4:21
It shows I truly love God 4:20, 5:1-3
Who in my life might say to me, “The way you love reminds me of God.”?
Whose love toward me reminds me of God’s love?
What difference does it make? 1 John 4:7-5:5
With such an emphasis on love in these verses, does God’s love actually change anything about my response to life? Life is unpredictable, and, left to my own devices, my natural response to life is fear. My tendency is to fear uncertainties, discomfort, and hardships, to flee what’s hard, and to fight against heartache. I fear these situations because each one threatens loss: separation in relationships, lack of comfort, and loss of perceived control. So what does God’s love have to do with my fear?
John had previously introduced God as light, which means He is perfect, and so is His love.
His perfectly present love cannot be hindered by disaster.
His perfectly whole love cannot be severed by sickness.
His perfectly sufficient love cannot be used up in need.
His perfectly unwavering love cannot be swayed by politics.
His perfectly stable love cannot be threatened by danger.
His perfectly gentle love cannot be cut off by violence.
His perfectly powerful love cannot be overcome by demons.
His perfectly eternal love cannot be manipulated by time.
This kind of Romans 8 love walks into my life, and suddenly my heart looks like a hoarder’s house, fears stuffed to the brim and life consumed by them. What’s all this doing in here?!
His perfect love casts out fear.
If God’s love has made itself at home in your heart, what are the fears that He would take to the curb on trash day?
And how does God’s love change how I react to people? Left to my own devices, my natural reaction to people is reservation. If God’s love for me was dependent on my gold-star efforts to love people, I’d still be waiting for the sticker. It’s not easy to love, and more often than not, my account feels overdrawn. I’m the classic introvert, storing up time alone and calculating whether I have enough to run on for time in a crowd.
If God commanded the kind of love Jesus showed, and didn’t resource us for it, we’d fail to obey. And this is why John points to the Spirit in us, differentiating our ability to love naturally and our ability to love supernaturally. God’s love revealed in Jesus’ life isn’t a show of extroversion; it’s a supernatural sacrifice of self.
If I lean on myself, I don’t feel loving. And that’s why I so often desperately pray: Lord, You’ll have to love this person through me, using my physical presence with them to show Your love. I don’t have it in me, but You do, and You’re in me. Love them through the words I speak. Love them through the food I prepare. Love them through the adjustments I make. Show up for them through me. Only because of the Spirit, His command to love is not burdensome.
Is your love more dependent on your personality or on the Spirit?
How have you loved us? 1 John 4:7-5:5
I have loved you, says the Lord…
'“I have loved you,” says the LORD. But you say, “How have you loved us?”' (Malachi 1:2).
I picture these people, arms crossed and chins lifted, with Oh, really? written all over their raised eyebrows. They dared God to show them evidence of His love.
When we read “God is love”, declared twice between 1 John 4:7-5:5, I wonder if we secretly ask the same question that Israel asked thousands of years ago. The grand, eternal scale of God’s love seems so elaborate, that perhaps everyday life raises doubts about whether His love is tangible in our personal experiences. Or maybe we think Israel was justified in their stance since Jesus had not yet come to earth.
If the people of Israel unrolled an inspired scroll and rolled up their sleeves with a passion to find answers, the record of how they had experienced God’s love would have been clear long before Jesus appeared. Throughout the plotline of history, God had been lavishing covenant-keeping, unfailing love and kindness on His children.
Peering over Israel’s shoulders, we can ask if there's really evidence of His love for them and for us:
Has God answered any specific prayers you prayed?
That was His love. Genesis 24:12-21
Has God ever taken the little you had and made much of it?
That was His love. Genesis 32:10
Has God shown kindness in unfair circumstances?
That was His love. Genesis 39:21
Has God ever forgiven you?
That was His love. Numbers 14:19
Did God bring redemption when all hope was lost?
That was His love. Ruth 2:20
Has God brought you relief from self-inflicted hardship?
That is His love. Ezra 9:6-9
Has God stayed when He could have left?
That is His love. Nehemiah 9:17
Has God been with you in your anguish?
That is His love. Psalm 31:7
Has God been merciful to you in your sin?
That is His love. Psalm 51:1
Did you ever have a season of flourishing?
That was God’s love. Psalm 52:8
Did you ever feel fortified with strength?
That was God’s love. Psalm 59:16
Has God delivered you from the depths?
That was His love. Psalm 86:13
Did you ever fear slipping, but you were supported?
That was God’s love. Psalm 94:18
Jesus is the climax of this love and our reason to exclaim, “How you have loved us!”